Showing posts with label Bailout. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bailout. Show all posts

Friday, February 14, 2020

Why Bail-Ins in Europe Are Not Likely in the USA



The public was outraged over the use of tax dollars to bail out banks during the 2007-2009 financial crisis. Congress passed the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Act of January 2010, which eliminated the option of bank bailouts but opened the door for bank bail-ins. The problem was that the banks in trouble were all the big boys in New York, which did not involve moms and pops on main street America as they saw it. The banks all repaid the $700 billion bailout, but this entire issue is being misrepresented by people promoting gold who advocate that you can lose all your money in banks so you better buy gold.
What they are not telling people is that you are covered by FDIC for $250,000. That was not changed by Dodd-Frank. Additionally, bail-ins would be political suicide and it would also undermine the entire economy. There is no way that Congress would ever vote for bail-ins in a crisis.
The situation in Europe is entirely different. Because they created the euro but did NOT consolidate the debts, the central objection came from Germany that they would not allow their money to be sent to bail out banks in Italy or Greece. Thus, the bail-in policy was adopted in Cyprus. The EU is by no means a single political government or economy. They integrated only to a limited extent. They still retain the separation between members with each even retaining their own central banks. Hence, the bail-in was NECESSARY in Europe because there is no actual central government as in the United States.
Consequently, in Europe they can still point the finger at individual states. That is not the way politics works in the United States. If they refused to bailout big banks, they would set off a contagion that would wipe out countless smaller banks throughout the nation. That would be a political disaster politically which is entirely different in Europe.

Thursday, October 24, 2019

Bail-In v Bailout of Banks in USA




QUESTION: Might you clarify this response you gave on one of your very recent blogs. You said bail-in may NOT be permitted on US soil. Did you mean that despite the laws written in the USA to allow it, you don’t think it is likely to happen to USA citizens banking in the USA?
OR were you only meaning in regards to overseas banks with locations within the USA would most likely not use bail-in.
OR because of all the EU money fleeing to USD/USA that the banks stable in the USA (for now) and thus no bail-in needed?
Do you think there would EVER be the case for a USA bank bail-in? Or is this just more conspiracy talk? For obvious reasons, this is of great concern to all of us as this USD repo madness, liquidity crisis and DB’s derivative contagion begins to spread throughout Europe into the next ECM turn in mid-January 2020.
Thank you in advance for your efforts and response to this question.
L
ANSWER: The bail-in laws were passed during the last crisis which was a popular response at that time because no bankers were ever punished for what they did in New York City. To the extent that FDIC exists, they would certainly honor that or it would be political suicide. However, the fine print is FDIC cover per person. Putting money at 5 different banks would seem to get around their limitations, but I would not count on that.
The gray area comes in two aspects.
  1. First, there are at any given time money from one bank which can be at another (REPO) which is also why there is a liquidity crisis
  2. Second, there are business accounts which exceed $100,000
The problem with a bail-in is that the ramifications would be far worse than the Great Depression. You would destroy businesses that would then be unable to make payroll and the unemployment would be massive – far greater than the 25% high of the Great Depression.
The BAIL-IN policy of Europe is a different animal altogether. This has nothing to do with bailing-out bankers. This stems from the refusal to consolidate debts. If banks failed in Southern Europe, then a bailout would mean money from the north could go to the south. This is the structural design. It is WHY Europe adopted the bail-in, quite different from the question of bankers’ conduct. Germany’s demand to join the Euro was that there would be no consolidation of debts. As I have said, the EU is like a family reunion with the cousin who is the drunk than people smile at, but would never lend him a dime. You can pretend it one happy family, but that is just the surface.
A bail-in would actually be devastating economically. It defeats the very idea of banking for if the burden is shifted to depositors to monitor banks when we have agencies who are supposed to do that, then why do we need governments or pay taxes?
Despite the laws, they were never thought threw and it is a huge difference between a regional bank and Goldman Sachs. The hatred was directed at the New York Banks – and rightly so. Because the federal court in New York City has protected the bankers, they have actually undermined the entire country by their stupid actions.

Sunday, October 6, 2019

US versus Europe bailout




The Coming European Crisis
QUESTION: Hi Martin,
first of all thank you for being alive and bring your knowledge to the world. I am also worried for when you will not be here, wondering if there is or will be anyone like you there?
I have a question as I am worried about my parents. They live in Europe, Spain, and they do not have much economic knowledge. They somehow trust in what the bank says, and for now they have their money on a fund which of course is giving almost nothing or even losing. What would you recommend to this kind of people if they just want to leave the money in a place without worrying too much, have better returns than a bank and have money available any time? Would you also recommend a private (non standard bank related) passive fund?
I am worried for the coming system crash as we are in difficult times and there is no “easy investment” by the looks of it. I hope to provide an educate answer to them and try to convince them to not to trust banks.
I guess this is the situation for a lot of people in the 70s, 80s in Europe. Last years most of them has lost a lot of money because of the bad advice from the banks whom they used (and somehow still but they are seing a bit the reality) to trust.
Thank you in advance.
JS
ANSWER: The real liquidity crisis hit in Europe. When the 2008-2009 crisis hit, the US bailed out the banks by taking the bad assets off their books. In Europe, they would not do that because it would mean money might flow from the north to the south to bail out banks the north had no respect for. Instead, they left the European banks with all the toxic losses and cut rates to negative, hoping the banks would make money on their own to cover their losses. That never happened. So Europe has been unable to recover all because of that policy which refused to consolidate the debts.
I do not like to recommend private funds that would impose a duty on me to constantly monitor them. I don’t have the time for that, and I do not charge for what I do so it would require ongoing resources and that would mandate a fee.
I also do not sell advertising on here because someone might think I am endorsing a particular investment just by allowing them to advertise. So I am careful about this sort of thing and understand that people respect me for my independence. I like to keep it that way. I even had a first-time attendee to one of our conferences remark I didn’t try to sell him anything. If I am trying to sell somebody something, then you do free seminars to get as many people to attend to listen to the sales pitch. Sorry, I am not selling investments.
All of that said, the best I can do is to say move the bulk of the money out of Europe to a major name money market fund investing in AAA short-term paper in the USA exclusively. This would be the best thing to do probably into 2021 before we would need to review the trend. Stay liquid. The politics in Europe will prevent any bailout. This will only lead to more discontent in Europe and put greater pressure on the separatist movements